Skip navigation - go directly to content.Eat Wild - The Clearinghouse for Information about Pasture-Based Farming
 

News Bulletins:     Nutrition     Animal Welfare     Environment      Farmers

Home
Shop for Local Grassfed Meat,
Eggs & Dairy
Shop the Eatwild Store for Books
& Kitchen Tools
Notes & News
Grass-Fed Basics
Fruits & Vegetables
Food Safety
Healthier Animals
Environmental Benefits
Benefits for Farmers
Health Benefits
Links
Meet Jo Robinson
How to Donate
Scientific References
Contact

  
   
 

 

 

 

From the News Archives...

Fat cows = fat people

Researchers have discovered that all fats are not created equal, especially when it comes to their ability to make you fat. There are two essential fats in our diet, omega-6 and omega-3 fatty acids. As a general rule, omega-3 fatty acids promote leanness and oemga-6 fatty acids promote obesity. (See references below.)

Omega-3 fatty acids are found in greens and omega-6 fatty acids are most abundant in grains. When animals are sent to the feedlot and switched from grass to grain, they have an abrupt shift in fatty acid balance: more omega-6s and fewer omega-3s. This is the recipe for obesity. The cattle put on weight more rapidly on a high-grain diet than they will on a pasture diet, even when they consume exactly the same number of calories. The reason? The omega-6 rich grain diet causes the animals to create more of an enzyme (fatty acid synthetase) that leads to the creation of fat. The graph below shows the difference in the amount of this fat-making enzyme produced in cows on an equal calorie, pasture or feedlot diet.

Fat Creating Enzyme

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

One of the main reasons that cattle are sent to the feedlot is precisely because they get fatter quicker. In the Canadian study represented by the above graph, the animals gained 1.3 kg a day on pasture and 1.55 kg per day on the feedlot diet. (The calories were adjusted so that they were exactly the same.) The end result is that the feedlot animals had more marbling and backfat. In other words, they were more obese. They also got higher grades because the Canadian grading system like the American system is based primarily on fat content. Interestingly, even though the forage-fed cattle received a lower quality grade, their meat was just as tender.

As you might expect, the meat of the animals also reflected the ratio of fats in their diet. Meat from the grain-fed animals was higher in omega-6 fatty acids and lower in omega-3 fatty acids than the meat from the leaner grassfed animals. Thus, when we eat meat from feedlot animals, we are treated to an abnormally high ratio of omega-6 to omega-3 fatty acids, just like the cattle. In humans, this type of diet is linked with a greater risk of diabetes and obesity, just as it is in livestock. You are what your animals eat.

The graph below shows that an animal fattened on grain has 14 times more omega-6 than omega-3 fatty acids in its meat. The grass-fed animal has a ratio of only 2.5, which is considered ideal for human health. Such a ratio is linked with a lower risk of cardiovascular disease, cancer, obesity, diabetes, depression, asthma, and auto-immune disorders. In our efforts to make our animals fatter quicker, we have unwittingly increased our risk of obesity, along with a host of other diseases.

Omega-6 to Omega-3 Fatty Acid Ratio in Beef

(The study on the fat-producing properties of pasture versus feedlot diets was conducted by Dr. Erasmus Okine at Alberta Agriculture Food and Rural Development in 1997. Read more about it here. To learn more about the omega-6/omega-3 fatty acid balance and obesity in humans, read The Omega Diet by Jo Robinson and Dr. Artemis Simopoulos or refer to the following scientific paper: Storlien, L., D. Pan, et al. (1993). "Skeletal Muscle Membrane Lipid Composition is Related to Adiposity in Man." Obesity Research 1 (Supplement 2): 775.

Return to News Archives

 

 


Pasture Perfect
by Jo Robinson

Learn more
or order now

 

Home | Grassfed Basics | Eatwild Store | Meet Jo | Notes & News| Food | Resources | Site Map | Contact | Support